It’s the Season of the Witchy Nail

Every product on this page was chosen by a Harper's BAZAAR editor. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.

Moody, spellbinding, and practically magic—here are 13 witchy nail ideas and polishes for fall

It’s the season of the witch—and the witchy nail. If you’re looking for a fall manicure that leans a little mystical and a little moody, without overtly referencing Halloween, turn to witches for nail inspiration. Even the fall 2026 runways featured a take on the trend, like the black stiletto nails seen above at the Matières Fécales show. The witchy fall 2026 nail ideas below—cat-eye finishes in color-shifting shades, almost-black polishes with unique designs, or nails sharp enough to draw blood—will conjure spooky season in the chicest way.

Black nail polish will always read “witchy”—go one step further by adding some interesting details, like a sheer base or smoky texture.

If you’re going to wear black nail polish, you might as well make it the best one: Chanel’s Le Vernis in Le Diable En Chanel.

There’s something inherently spellbinding about a cat-eye manicure. The color shifts and the depth—it’s mesmerizing, like peering into a crystal ball.

A cat-eye manicure requires special tools. Go the easy route with these press-on nails from Glamnetic that are available on Amazon.

These nails look black at first, but change the angle or the lighting, and you’ll see a green shade underneath that’s not unlike what you’d find bubbling in a cauldron.

If you’re a fan of a DIY manicure, pick up a bottle of Holo Taco’s color-shifting nail polish.

Ultra-long stiletto nails look inherently beautiful and dangerous. Play up that vibe even more by painting them in a sheer, blood-red shade.

This deep red polish is the perfect shade for fall and looks great on all skin tones.

By layering multiple shades of polish and chrome, color-shifting finishes, you can achieve a manicure that looks like a mood ring—or a portal to another dimension.

Consider this the perfect green-shift polish for October.

If you’ve read Sarah J. Maas’s best-selling Throne of Glass series, you know that the witches in that fantasy world—like the fan-favorite Manon Blackbeak—have deadly, silver-chrome nails of iron.

A chrome manicure always looks best when done by a pro at a salon. But the next best thing is this chrome-effect polish from our favorite drugstore brand, Sally Hansen.

Is Age Affecting the Health of Your Nails?

How to Recreate Anne Hathaway’s “Cherry Noir” Mani

Hailey Bieber Matches Her Nails to Her Hair

Nicole Kidman’s Cherry Blossom Nails Are So Easy

Here’s How to Get Selena Gomez’s 2026 Emmys Mani

Nicole Kidman and Sandra Bullock's Matching Nails

Square Nails Are Back; Just Ask Amal Clooney

“Pumpkin Cider” Nail Polish Is Perfect for Fall

How to Recreate Priyanka Chopra’s “Latte Nails”

The Nostalgic “Deep French Manicure” Is Back

Lavender Nails Are the New Quiet Luxury Manicure

We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back.