Every product on this page was chosen by a Harper's BAZAAR editor. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.
Design by Sarah Olivieri Beauty Makeup The 13 Best Eyeliners for Mature Eyes, According to Experts The 13 Best Eyeliners for Mature Eyes, According to Experts Enhance your makeup look with these easy, expert-approved formulas
Even the most tried-and-true makeup routines often require a refresh as we age, particularly when it comes to the best eyeliner for older women. Subtle shifts in eyelid texture, firmness, and moisture levels can change how liner sits on the skin. What once created crisp definition may now appear harsher, migrate throughout the day, or feel less comfortable on increasingly delicate lids.
New York City ophthalmologist Ashley Brissette explains, “The eyelid skin becomes thinner, and the tear film naturally becomes drier, which makes the eyes more sensitive to certain eyeliner formulas.” The expert advises avoiding waterproof liners, strong preservatives, fragrances, and pencils that can drag across the lid. Creamy, ophthalmologist-tested options tend to be gentler and more dependable for mature eyes .
And when it comes to technique, celebrity makeup artist Nick Barose tells Bazaar that he recommends keeping eyeliner slightly blurred rather than overly sharp or defined, as this can make it look harsh and even more aging. He often softens the line and lifts the outer corners for clients with droopy lids. Barose also recommends long-wearing gel formulas that glide smoothly and resist smudging.
Beauty expert Felicia Walker , 50, gravitates toward smoky tones like cocoa, navy, and maroon that bring soft definition without overpowering her features, and uses hers as a tool for expression and vibrancy . At the moment, she considers herself a super fan of Danessa Myricks Beauty's Colorfix Stix . “It lines, shades, sculpts, and brings 'Little Miss Main Character' energy to my eyes,” she explains.
Here, discover our short list of the best eyeliners for aging eyes worth adding to your routine. These coveted options are handpicked by makeup experts , eye doctors, and beauty lovers in the know to elevate your go-to look.
Creamy, blendable, and formulated to perform beautifully on both lash line and waterline, this pencil is a standout for bold definition. Once set, it resists smudging and fading while remaining comfortable on sensitive eyes.
This mechanical pencil is a low-maintenance staple for those who prefer to skip sharpening. The “no-tug” formula glides seamlessly, delivering rich pigment in a single stroke—a major perk for mature eyes. It creates a crisp line that resists smudging throughout the day.
This creamy kohl pencil is ideal for anyone whose eyes feel a bit drier or more fatigued throughout the day. The formula glides on without skipping—crucial for mature lids—and is infused with vitamin E to condition and caffeine to help visibly de-puff. The payoff is rich enough for definition but soft enough to smudge into a flattering, lived-in look.
If you're looking for intense color, this pencil truly delivers. I've personally been using this liner since my early 20s, and it's the one I can always count on for rich color and minimal irritation. It's been a steady favorite, even as my sometimes-sensitive eyes follow me into my late 30s.
This drugstore steal offers the intensity of a gel pot liner with the convenience of a pencil. It glides easily and sets down to a 36-hour wear that res…