Gaming & Live Streaming

The 10 greatest games to never get a GOTY nomination

If your favorite game wasn’t nominated, you’re not alone.

AAdmin
November 19, 2026
3 min read
The 10 greatest games to never get a GOTY nomination

By Lillian Ali Published Nov 18, 2026, 7:00 PM EST Polygon Lists It's ok to still be mad!

Image: Yacht Club Games via Polygon Add Polygon.com on Google Add as Preferred Source Follow on Google Discover Sign in to your Polygon.com account Summary Generate a summary of this story Like Like follow Follow followed Followed Thread 2 Log in Here is a fact-based summary of the story contents: Try something different: Show me the facts Explain it like I’m 5 Give me a lighthearted recap The Game Awards announced its 2026 nominations yesterday, though not without controversy. Grand Theft Auto 6 — a game that isn't even out yet — leads the pack with eight nominations, including Game of the Year. No indies managed to get a GOTY nomination this year, despite the release of acclaimed games like Mina the Hollower and Big Walk. Several blockbusters — including Polygon favorites like Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave and Pokémon Pokopia — were also snubbed for the night's biggest award.

While there's a lot to be said about 2026's Game Awards snubs , some of the greatest games of all time never received a GOTY nomination. While the games below may have been nominated (or won) in other Game Awards categories, they never got their fair shot at Game of the Year honors.

Where to play: PlayStation 4, Windows PC, Xbox One

Dark Souls 3 was a gorgeous, somber conclusion to FromSoftware's groundbreaking Dark Souls trilogy. By speeding up the pace of combat, Dark Souls 3 bridged Bloodborne and Elden Ring, streamlining an already iconic gameplay loop. To close out its trilogy, FromSoft proved it had complete mastery over the gameplay style it innovated years earlier.

Despite widespread acclaim, Dark Souls 3 was not nominated for Game of the Year in 2016, only getting a nod for Best RPG. Fans should take comfort in the fact that 2016 was an absolutely stacked year, though, with Overwatch , Doom , and Inside all competing for top honors. There's also the fact that very difficult games face an uphill battle in the GOTY race.

Where to play: Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Windows PC, Xbox One

Outer Wilds is hard to categorize. At once an open-world explorer, an action adventure title, and a puzzle game, it dropped a traditional combat focus in favor of rewarding curiosity and knowledge. Couple that with a tightly written story, and you have one of the most immersive, combat-free gaming experiences of the decade.

Outer Wilds faced even stiffer competition than Dark Souls 3. 2019 was a competitive year, with Control, Death Stranding, Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, The Outer Worlds, and the Resident Evil 2 remake fighting for top honors. Several other great games, like Disco Elysium, Fire Emblem: Three Houses, and Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order also failed to secure nominations. So, for an indie game — which tend to build popularity via word of mouth — Outer Wilds was always a deserving but unlikely nomination.

Where to play: Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Windows PC, Xbox One

NieR:Automata this relatively obscure spin-off of Square Enix's Drakengard series to mainstream audiences. Its intricate, existential story and seamless transitions between bullet-hell, hack-and-slash, and side-scrolling gameplay left a mark on millions of gamers worldwide.

Automata lost the nomination race to games like Breath of the Wild, Super Mario Odyssey , and Horizon Zero Dawn — games with enormous mainstream appeal. Though Automata was a breakout critical an…